Skip to content
Get your free gift ENES

Why this page exists

Kindle or print?

Every now and then, readers tell me they bought the same book in more than one format. I wondered why. Thinking it through, I arrived at the answers on this page. Maybe they make the choice easier for you, including everything that speaks against it.

Painting of a reading table by a window with an open print book, an e-reader, and a steaming cup.

The short answer first: If you read a book once and then move on, the Kindle edition is all you need.

It costs less, it’s there instantly, and it takes up no space. You won’t miss anything. The text is the same in every edition, word for word. Everything else on this page only matters if you notice that a book stays with you longer than the time it takes to read it.

The editions in detail

What each edition does well, and what it doesn’t

No format is better than the others. They’re made for different moments. Each one also lists what it isn’t good for.

Kindle

  • Weighs nothing, and a thousand books fit on one device
  • Less expensive than any print edition
  • There instantly, even at eleven thirty at night
  • The search function finds any passage again
  • Adjustable font size, helpful for tired eyes
  • Highlight in colors, add notes, and your notes are always with you
  • The book itself can’t get lost
  • No paper, no ink, no shipping
  • A revised version can be delivered digitally
  • Needs power and a device
  • Slips out of sight more easily, and out of mind
  • More screen time, unless you read on an e-reader
  • On a phone, everything else competes for your attention
  • You can’t lend it to anyone or put it in their hands
  • You can’t resell it. A print book you pass on afterward can even end up costing less
  • No paper to touch and smell, your senses stay on the sidelines
  • Following the line with your finger is awkward
  • The table of contents isn’t as quick to flip to as in a print book

For on the go, for the first read, and for everything you want to find again.

Paperback

  • Paper, weight, scent: more of your senses are involved
  • You can lend it and give it away
  • Work with a pen, underline, write in the margins
  • Copy a page for yourself and pin it up
  • It sits on the shelf and catches your eye at the right moment
  • Reading without a screen, without power, without a battery level
  • Fewer distractions than on any device
  • You can resell it later
  • It has some weight and takes up shelf space
  • More expensive than the digital edition
  • Shipping takes a few days
  • Paper and ink use raw materials
  • You only get a revised edition by buying it again

For books you want to work with, and for everything you plan to pass on.

An observation

Why some readers own both

Few readers tell me why. So I laid the formats side by side and looked at what each one can do.

In the end it came down to two sentences: Digital, you can find any passage in seconds. In print, you can work with it and pass it on. That’s my reading, not theirs.

It’s certainly not a must, and for most books it isn’t necessary. If you own both editions yourself, I’d love to hear how that happened. Write to me, I read every email.

Painting of an open book page with underlined lines, handwritten notes in the margin, and a pencil.

If you pass it on

A book you can talk about

A second reason people mention: Someone gives a book away not to get rid of it, but because they want to talk about it. A mother and daughter read the same chapter and call each other afterward. Two friends underline different sentences.

You don’t need any special offer from me for that. All you need is two copies and someone you want to talk with. If you’d like, write to me afterward and tell me what came of it. Those are my favorite emails to read.

And if you’re unsure

Start small

Choose the least expensive edition and read. If the book keeps working in your mind after the last chapter, you’ll know more is worth it. If not, you spent little and read a book. Both are fine.

And if you’re not sure which of my books might suit you, take a quick walk through the Reader Compass first.

Text